Re: Writer's question

From: Ian Greig (ian.greig@CLARA.NET)
Date: Thu Jan 11 2001 - 19:42:42 AEDT


Robert Waltz, you said on 11/1/01 5:01 AM

>Nisus is a lousy layout tool; if you're doing camera-ready work, you
>need something else (not Word; Quark XPress or FrameMaker).


Well, Bob, I agree with you that it doesn't do professional layout which
is why many of us use the above or PageMaker (in my case). But referring
to Mark's original question, I would want to say it is very good for what
I call quick-and-dirty layout ­ text flowing round quickly inserted
inserted graphics, that sort of thing ­ AND the booklet feature eg 4pp A5
which I use *all the time* for handouts. As long as you don't need uneven
columns . . .

Nisus
>doesn't have an irritating little icon making irritating little
>suggestions. :-)

Worth buying for this lack-of-feature alone

> Nisus doesn't do tables or outlining.

Now, I feel this is a little on the harsh side. Nisus Table Tool requires
one to jump through some hoops to do large or multi-page tables, but it
does produce an elegant result. Word tables always had a certain look . .
. not elegant. I didn't like the Table Tool at first - bit of a learning
curve - but it has become more of a friend now, and I use it regularly.

And outlining . . . major topic of discussion (check the archives). This
is a strange drawback for something which is a writer's tool, since it
seems that many if not most writers use outlining as a means of
organisation.

Then there are those of us who write first, and then reduce to outline to
speak or produce handout notes . . .

(Addressing Mark really but reflecting on Bob's comment) Nisus *can*
outline, using macros. It isn't perfect. But then Word's approach was
truly barbarian (might be better now, I haven't checked it out on the
family Windoze rig). It seems most on this list use alternatives such as
More (available free, very powerful), Acta (also available free?? - I
never quiter got on with Acta) and Inspiration, which costs but offers a
useful and flexible outliner *and* concept mapping. Getting to and from
from Nisus to one of these is still current debate as only the
Australians seem to know how to do it . . . I think it helps to figure it
out if you put beer on your cornflakes, from what I've gleaned . . .

Ian Greig



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Mon Jan 15 2001 - 23:00:13 AEDT